Updated October 26, 2026 · By Quinn Sutherland
The cheapest broad index funds a beginner can buy cost 0% to 0.04% a year. Fidelity’s ZERO funds charge 0%. Fidelity’s FXAIX charges 0.015%. Schwab’s SWPPX and SWTSX charge 0.02% and 0.03%. Vanguard’s VTI and VOO ETFs charge 0.03%, and its Admiral mutual funds (VTSAX, VFIAX) charge 0.04%. On $10,000, the most expensive of these costs $4 a year more than the cheapest. These are examples of each category, not picks. This is not financial advice, and I don’t know your situation.
At that price, expense ratio stops being the deciding factor. What matters more is where your first dollar gets stuck. Some funds can’t leave the broker that issues them. Some cost about $75 a trade to buy at another broker. And in a regular taxable account, selling to move costs capital gains tax that dwarfs any fee you saved. This guide matches the fund and broker to your starting balance and account type, so that a move later doesn’t force a sale, charge a fee, or break a wash-sale rule.
At a glance
| Fund | Tracks | Wrapper | Expense ratio | Cost per $10,000/yr | Minimum | Can it go to another broker? | Tax efficiency in a taxable account |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FZROX (Fidelity ZERO Total Market) | Fidelity’s own US total-market index | Mutual fund | 0% | $0 | None | No. Fidelity accounts only, so leaving means selling | Moderate |
| FNILX (Fidelity ZERO Large Cap) | Fidelity’s own large-cap index (not the S&P 500 itself) | Mutual fund | 0% | $0 | None | No. Same as FZROX | Moderate |
| FXAIX | S&P 500 | Mutual fund | 0.015% | $1.50 | None | Usually transfers in kind; buying more elsewhere may carry a fee | Moderate |
| SWPPX | S&P 500 | Mutual fund | 0.02% | $2 | None | Same as FXAIX | Moderate |
| SWTSX | Dow Jones US Total Stock Market | Mutual fund | 0.03% | $3 | None | Same as FXAIX | Moderate |
| VOO / IVV | S&P 500 | ETF | 0.03% | $3 | One share, or less with fractional shares | Yes. Moves in kind to almost any broker | High |
| VTI | CRSP US Total Market | ETF | 0.03% | $3 | One share, or less with fractional shares | Yes. Same as VOO / IVV | High |
| VTSAX | CRSP US Total Market (same portfolio as VTI) | Mutual fund (Admiral) | 0.04% | $4 | $3,000 | Usually transfers in kind; buying more elsewhere can cost a transaction fee | High (it shares a portfolio with VTI) |
| VFIAX | S&P 500 (same portfolio as VOO) | Mutual fund (Admiral) | 0.04% | $4 | $3,000 | Same as VTSAX | High |
Fund companies change expense ratios. The figures here are the published ones as of this update, so check the prospectus before you buy. “Moderate” tax efficiency means a mutual fund without an ETF share class, which can pay out taxable capital gains in some years. In an IRA or 401(k) that column doesn’t matter.
Where your first dollar gets stuck
There are three exit costs. None of them shows up in an expense ratio.
1. Broker lock. Fidelity offers its ZERO funds only to people with Fidelity accounts. If you move your account to another broker, plan on selling them first. Confirm with both brokers before you start a transfer. In an IRA the sale costs you nothing except a few days out of the market. In a taxable account the sale is a taxable event.
2. Cross-broker transaction fees. You can usually move a Vanguard, Schwab or Fidelity mutual fund to a different broker without selling it. Adding money to it there is the problem. 24/7 Wall St reported that Schwab charges $74.95 to buy VTSAX. Check your broker’s current fee schedule, because these change. If you add $200 a month, a $74.95 fee on each purchase takes 37% of every deposit. ETFs trade commission-free at the major brokers no matter who issued them.
3. Tax on selling. In a taxable account, any move that requires a sale turns paper gains into reportable gains. IRS Topic 409 explains how this works. Shares held more than a year get long-term rates of 0%, 15% or 20% depending on income. Shares held a year or less are taxed as ordinary income.
ETFs avoid all three. That’s why I treat the wrapper as a bigger decision than a 0.01% to 0.03% gap in fees.
By-scenario matrix: starting balance × account type
| Starting balance | Account | What tends to fit (examples, not picks) | Broker note | Portability | Tax cost if you leave the broker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0–$500 | Taxable | Broad ETF bought as fractional shares (VTI, ITOT, SCHB, VOO, IVV) | Pick a broker that sells fractional ETF shares in dollar amounts | Moves in kind | None to transfer; tax only if you sell |
| $0–$500 | Roth or traditional IRA | Any $0-minimum index fund where you open the account (FZROX, FXAIX, SWTSX) or a fractional ETF | ZERO funds are fine if you accept staying at Fidelity | ZERO funds must be sold; others usually move in kind | None. Sales inside an IRA aren’t taxed |
| $500–$3,000 | Taxable | Broad ETF | The ZERO-fund lock costs the most in this row | Moves in kind | None to transfer |
| $500–$3,000 | IRA | ETF, or the broker’s own $0-minimum index fund | Mutual funds let you invest exact dollar amounts automatically | Depends on the fund | None |
| $3,000–$10,000 | Taxable | Broad ETF; at Vanguard, an Admiral fund is also an option | Vanguard has let investors convert mutual fund shares into the same fund’s ETF shares without a taxable sale (not the other way round). Check current policy | ETF moves anywhere; Admiral funds may carry fees elsewhere | None for an ETF; a sale costs capital gains tax |
| $3,000–$10,000 | IRA | Admiral funds become available; any low-cost index fund works | Choose the platform you’ll stay on | Depends on the fund | None |
| $10,000+ | Taxable | ETF core, plus a loss-harvest partner on a different index picked in advance (see below) | Keep it all at one broker so you can track wash sales | Moves in kind | Selling to move could cost hundreds or thousands at this size |
| $10,000+ | IRA | The lowest-cost broad fund on your platform | Loss harvesting doesn’t apply | Depends on the fund | None |
| Any | 401(k) | The plan’s lowest-cost broad index option, from its menu | You don’t choose the broker | When you leave the job, a rollover to an IRA usually arrives as cash | None if it’s a direct rollover |
One line from that table carries most of the risk: a 0% broker-locked fund in a taxable account at a broker you might leave. In every other row the lock either doesn’t matter or costs only a few days out of the market.
For how the IRA types differ, see Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA for Beginners (2026 Guide).
Worked example: $4,000 in a taxable account, with a move planned in five years
Here’s the situation. Someone opens a taxable account at Fidelity with $4,000 and adds $200 a month. They expect to consolidate everything at a different broker in about five years. They compare FZROX (0%) with a total-market ETF such as VTI or ITOT (0.03%).
Step 1: Growth. Assume a 7% annual return, compounded monthly. That’s an assumption, not a forecast. After 60 months the account is worth about $19,990, of which $16,000 is money they put in.
Step 2: Fee difference. The average balance over five years is about $11,000. At 0.03% a year, that’s $11,000 × 0.0003 × 5 ≈ $17 in total. That’s what FZROX saves over the five years.
Step 3: The move.
- ETF: it transfers in kind. Nothing is sold and no tax is due.
- FZROX: it has to be sold first. The gain is about $19,990 − $16,000 = $3,990. At a 15% long-term federal rate that’s roughly $600, plus state tax where it applies. Shares bought in the final 12 months would count as short-term gains, but those gains are small in this example.
Step 4: The comparison. The cheaper fund saves $17 and costs about $600 if they leave. That’s a loss of roughly 35 times the saving.
Step 5: When FZROX wins anyway. If they never leave Fidelity, or the account is an IRA, the $17 is pure savings. A third option is to leave the FZROX in a Fidelity account, stop adding to it, and send new money elsewhere. That costs no tax, just one more login.
To rerun this with your own numbers, use the SEC’s compound interest calculator at Investor.gov. Enter the return minus the expense ratio as the interest rate.
“Same fund, different wrapper”: overlap that isn’t diversification
| Fund A | Fund B | How they’re related | Does holding both diversify? | OK as a loss-harvest swap? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VTI | VTSAX | Two share classes of one Vanguard fund | No | No. Treat them as substantially identical |
| VOO | VFIAX | Two share classes of Vanguard 500 Index | No | No |
| VXUS | VTIAX | Two share classes of Vanguard Total International | No | No |
| VOO | IVV, SPLG, FXAIX, SWPPX | Different issuers, same S&P 500 index | No | Grey area; many tax preparers avoid it |
| VTI | VOO | Different indexes, but the S&P 500 is most of the total US market and the top holdings are identical | Only slightly (VTI adds mid and small caps) | Different index, but the overlap is heavy, so it’s a judgment call |
Owning FXAIX in a 401(k) and VOO in a Roth IRA gives you one investment: the S&P 500, held twice. To actually diversify, add a different asset class (international stocks or bonds) instead of a second wrapper. See How to Build an Investment Portfolio That Matches Your Risk.
Tax-loss harvesting: the pairs that work, and the wash-sale trap
Tax-loss harvesting means selling a fund that’s down to lock in a loss for tax purposes, then buying something similar right away so you stay invested. IRS Publication 550 disallows the loss if you buy “substantially identical” stock or securities within 30 days before or after the sale. The disallowed loss is added to the cost basis of the new shares. Pub 550 doesn’t list which funds count as identical. It says to weigh the facts and circumstances. A swap into a fund on a different index, preferably from a different issuer, is the safer side of that line.
An earlier version of this article listed VTI ↔ VTSAX and VOO ↔ SPLG as harvesting pairs. That was wrong. VTI and VTSAX are the same fund. VOO and SPLG track the same index. Here are corrected swaps:
| If you’re selling at a loss | Swaps that track a different index | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| VTI (CRSP US Total Market) | ITOT (S&P Total Market, iShares) or SCHB (Dow Jones US Broad Stock Market, Schwab) | VTSAX or any other VTI share class |
| VXUS (FTSE Global All Cap ex US) | IXUS (MSCI ACWI ex USA IMI, iShares); VEU uses a different FTSE index but is also Vanguard | VTIAX |
| An S&P 500 fund (VOO, IVV, FXAIX) | A total-market fund from another issuer, such as ITOT or SCHB | Every other S&P 500 fund |
Wash sales people trigger by accident:
- Automatic dividend reinvestment in the fund you just sold, inside the 30-day window. Turn it off before you harvest.
- A scheduled purchase of the same fund in your IRA or 401(k). The IRS has said a repurchase in your IRA can also trigger a wash sale. Pause or redirect those contributions.
- Swapping back on day 29. Count 31 days.
What a harvested loss is worth: Per Topic 409, losses first offset your capital gains. Then up to $3,000 a year ($1,500 if married filing separately) can offset ordinary income, and any unused amount carries forward. Say a $15,000 position falls to $12,000 and you harvest the $3,000 loss against ordinary income in the 24% bracket. That saves about $720 this year. Some of that is a deferral, not a permanent saving: the replacement fund now has a lower cost basis, so you’ll owe more tax when you eventually sell it.
The only losses I’ve ever harvested came from speculative positions I shouldn’t have bought. I’ve had three of those. In my experience, harvesting is cleanup after a mistake, not a strategy in itself.
Harvesting does nothing in IRAs or 401(k)s. In a small taxable account, the bookkeeping often costs more effort than the tax it saves.
How much money do I need to start investing in an index fund?
As little as $1 at a broker that sells fractional shares or offers $0-minimum mutual funds. Fidelity sells fractional ETF shares in dollar amounts. Schwab and Vanguard run their own programs, with rules about which ETFs qualify, so check your broker’s fractional-share page rather than assuming. Without fractional shares, an ETF costs one share, which is a few hundred dollars for VTI and more for VOO. Vanguard’s Admiral mutual funds require $3,000.
How much you can afford to lose matters more than how much you start with. Money you’ll need in the next few years shouldn’t be in stocks at all.
Should I buy an ETF or a mutual fund version of the same index?
In a taxable account, the ETF usually comes out ahead. It moves to any broker in kind, every major broker trades it commission-free, and the ETF structure tends to pay out fewer capital gains. VTSAX is an exception: it shares a portfolio with VTI, so it’s about as tax-efficient.
In an IRA, the mutual fund’s main advantage counts. You can invest exact dollar amounts automatically, such as $150 every payday, without fractional-share rules getting in the way. Fees are close enough that convenience can decide it. For more on how ETFs work, see What Are ETFs and Should You Buy Them?.
S&P 500 fund or total stock market fund: which is better for a beginner?
Experts disagree, and over most periods the results have been close. An S&P 500 fund holds about 500 large US companies. A total-market fund holds those same companies plus thousands of mid-size and small ones, but because funds are weighted by company size, the large companies still dominate it. A total-market fund is slightly broader. An S&P 500 fund is easier to find in 401(k) menus. Pick one as your US core, not both. As the overlap table shows, holding both mostly duplicates what you own.
Most actively managed large-cap funds have trailed the S&P 500 over long periods, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA scorecards. That’s the main argument for either type of index fund.
Can I move my index fund to a different brokerage later, and does it cost anything?
| What you hold | IRA | Taxable account |
|---|---|---|
| ETF (VTI, VOO, ITOT, SCHB) | Moves in kind, no sale | Moves in kind, no sale, no tax |
| Fidelity ZERO fund | Must sell; no tax; a few days out of the market | Must sell, so capital gains tax is due |
| Other company’s mutual fund (VTSAX, SWTSX, FXAIX) | Usually moves in kind | Usually moves in kind, but buying more at the new broker may cost a transaction fee, so many people sell anyway and owe tax |
| 401(k) holdings | When you leave the job, a rollover usually arrives as cash | n/a |
Brokers sometimes charge an outgoing transfer fee. The receiving broker often reimburses it if you ask. Confirm both brokers’ rules before you start a transfer, because they change.
How are index funds taxed in a regular brokerage account vs an IRA?
Taxable account: dividends are taxed in the year you receive them, even if they’re reinvested. Mutual funds can also pay out capital gains that you didn’t choose to realize. When you sell, the gain is short-term if you held a year or less and long-term if you held longer (Topic 409). Your broker reports all of this on Form 1099.
Traditional IRA or 401(k): nothing is taxed while the money stays inside. Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
Roth IRA: nothing is taxed inside, and qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
So in an IRA, the fund’s tax efficiency and the tax cost of moving drop out of the decision. Tax laws vary by jurisdiction, including state income tax on gains, and they change. Treat this as an explanation of concepts, not tax advice.
Can I lose money in an index fund?
Yes. An index fund falls when its market falls. Between mid-February and late March 2020, the S&P 500 lost roughly a third of its value. I know three people who sold during that drop and locked in the loss. In a broad index fund, losses are usually temporary if you can wait, but recovery has taken years in past downturns and there’s no guarantee it will happen. A narrower index (one sector or one country) can stay down much longer. Low fees don’t protect you from any of that.
In practice, the funds that held up best were the ones whose owners understood what they owned well enough not to sell at the bottom.
Common mistakes, with the numbers
- Buying a broker-locked 0% fund in a taxable account at a broker you may leave. You save a few dollars a year and can owe hundreds in tax later. The worked example above shows $17 saved against about $600 owed.
- Paying about $75 a trade to buy another company’s mutual fund. On a $200 monthly deposit, that’s more than a third of each deposit. The same company’s ETF is usually commission-free.
- Waiting until you can “afford” a full share of a few hundred dollars when your broker sells fractional shares. Months out of the market cost more than 0.03%.
- Holding two S&P 500 funds (or VTI plus VOO) and calling it diversification. You own one index twice.
- Harvesting losses into a share-class twin (VTI to VTSAX, VXUS to VTIAX). The loss is likely disallowed.
- Leaving dividend reinvestment on in the fund you just harvested, or buying it in your IRA within 30 days.
- Choosing by expense ratio alone when every fund in the top table is within 0.04% of the others.
Stop and get professional help when…
A CPA or enrolled agent for tax questions, or a fee-only fiduciary advisor for planning questions, is worth paying for when:
- Moving brokers would mean selling $10,000 or more of appreciated holdings in a taxable account.
- You’re harvesting losses while the same index or a close match is also held in an IRA, a 401(k) or a spouse’s account.
- Your income is close to the edge of the 0% long-term capital gains bracket, so the timing of a sale changes your rate.
- You have carried-over losses, inherited shares, or company stock and stock options in the same account.
- You’ll need the money within a few years. That’s a question about whether to be in stocks at all, not which fund to buy.
A few remaining questions
Should I invest a tax refund or bonus all at once? Studies of historical data have generally found that investing a lump sum right away ended up ahead of spreading it out more often than not. Spreading purchases over a few months is a reasonable way to feel less exposed to a drop the week after you buy. See Best Way to Invest a Tax Refund: A Real-Numbers Guide.
Can I automate this? Yes. All three big brokers let you set up recurring purchases from a linked bank account. Mutual funds take exact dollar amounts. ETFs need fractional-share support for the same thing. I’ve added a small amount every month since my first $200 in 2018, and the automatic transfer, not the fund I picked, is why the account grew. See Best Ways to Automate Your Savings (With Real Numbers).
Vanguard, Fidelity or Schwab? Their fees on broad index funds are nearly identical. Choose the platform you expect to keep for decades, and if you’re unsure, use ETFs so the choice doesn’t lock you in.
This is not financial advice. I explain fund structures, fees and tax mechanics based on what I’ve learned investing since 2018. I’m not a financial advisor, CPA or CFP. Expense ratios, broker fees, fractional-share rules and tax law change, so check the current prospectus, your broker’s fee schedule and a tax professional before acting. Index funds carry market risk: if you invest $5,000 and the market drops 30%, your account shows $3,500. Past returns don’t predict future ones, and the 7% used in the examples is an illustration, not an expectation.